The short version

All seven are large, full-power recreational lakes. They mostly differ on drive time, what $750k buys, and STR-friendliness.

🥇
Best Value + Easiest Rentals
Kerr Lake (NC/VA)
~1.5 hr · $750k buys top-tier waterfront · most STR-permissive, but the smallest rental market.
🥈
Best Rental Income
Smith Mountain Lake (VA)
Strongest STR market on the list · strictest zoning — verify the exact parcel before offering.
🥉
Best All-Rounder
Lake Gaston (NC/VA)
~1.9 hr · mature rental scene · budget sits below median waterfront price.

Compare the Lakes

Filter and sort. Heart ❤️ any lake to save it to Our Picks. Add your own vote so everyone can see where the family lands.

Filter
Sort

At-a-Glance Comparison

Drive times from central Raleigh. Pricing and STR rules as of 2025–2026.

Lake Drive Size $750k buys waterfront? STR Climate Rental Demand

⚠️ Verify Before You Make an Offer

  • STR rules are hyper-local and change fast. Confirm for the exact county, town, and parcel with the planning office.
  • At Smith Mountain Lake, Franklin County currently limits STRs largely to agricultural zoning by SUP — wrong zone = can't legally rent short-term.
  • Lake Anna, Lake Murray, and SML require septic inspections, registration fees, and management plans for STRs.
  • Lake Murray sits at the very edge of your 4.5-hr limit (~4h20). Closer communities may qualify; farther shores may not.

Waterfront & Lake-Access Lots Under $150k

Land to build your dream home. Update status/price as you check listings — this list isn't wired to a live MLS feed, so it only stays current if the family keeps it updated.

Homes Under $750k

Active listings across your target lakes. Each card shows a real monthly-cost-vs-rental-income estimate using the assumptions in ⚙️ up top — tune those to see how the picture changes.

❤️

No picks saved yet

Heart any lake, lot, or home from the other tabs to save it here for the family to discuss.

Sources & Notes — Drive times via Google Maps / rome2rio. Pricing and STR rules from local Realtor market reports, Redfin, Zillow, county ordinances (2025–2026). Figures are directional — verify current listings and ordinances before purchase. Compiled June–July 2026.